Punch You in the Eye
A Phish original · from Live / Non-album original
Gap
7
8 shows ago
Last played
Jul 25, 2026
Madison Square Garden · New York, NY
Play rank
#69
of 957 · 172 plays
Points
150
Rarity #81 in the catalogue
Performance history
- Times played
- 172
- First played
- Aug 17, 1989The Front · Burlington, VT, US
- Last played
- Jul 25, 2026Madison Square Garden · New York, NY
- Album
- Live / Non-album original
- Rarity score
- 150 pts
How players call it
Times picked
106
Hit rate
25%
26 paid off
How often Pick5 players put this song on a card, and how often the band rewarded them.
Recent appearances
The last 12 times Phish played it, and where it landed in the night.
- Jul 25, 2026Madison Square Garden · New York, NYSet 1, song 4
- Jul 11, 2026Ruoff Music Center · Noblesville, INSet 1, song 2
- Apr 30, 2026Sphere · Las Vegas, NVSet 1, song 7
- Dec 28, 2025Madison Square Garden · New York, NY, USSet 1, song 6
- Sep 14, 2025Coca-Cola Amphitheater · Birmingham, AL, USSet 1, song 1
- Jul 23, 2025Forest Hills Stadium · Queens, NY, USSet 2, song 9
- Jul 15, 2025TD Pavilion at the Mann · Philadelphia, PA, USSet 1, song 1
- Jun 28, 2025Moody Center · Austin, TX, USSet 1, song 1
- Apr 23, 2025Bill Graham Civic Auditorium · San Francisco, CA, USSet 1, song 2
- Aug 2, 2024Ruoff Music Center · Noblesville, IN, USSet 1, song 1
- Dec 31, 2023Madison Square Garden · New York, NY, USSet 1, song 13
- Aug 25, 2023Saratoga Performing Arts Center · Saratoga Springs, NY, USSet 1, song 6
Think you can call the setlist?
Pick five songs before Phish takes the stage and score them live against everyone else in the room.
Play free