I Always Wanted It This Way
A Phish original · from Big Boat
Gap
65
66 shows ago
Last played
Jun 24, 2025
Petersen Events Center · Pittsburgh, PA, US
Play rank
#257
of 957 · 23 plays
Points
281
Rarity #268 in the catalogue
Performance history
- Times played
- 23
- First played
- Oct 15, 2016North Charleston Coliseum · North Charleston, SC, US
- Last played
- Jun 24, 2025Petersen Events Center · Pittsburgh, PA, US
- Album
- Big Boat
- Rarity score
- 281 pts
How players call it
Times picked
9
Hit rate
—
Needs 10 picks
How often Pick5 players put this song on a card, and how often the band rewarded them.
Recent appearances
The last 12 times Phish played it, and where it landed in the night.
- Jun 24, 2025Petersen Events Center · Pittsburgh, PA, USSet 1, song 4
- Apr 18, 2025Climate Pledge Arena · Seattle, WA, USSet 2, song 12
- Dec 28, 2024Madison Square Garden · New York, NY, USSet 2, song 15
- Aug 2, 2024Ruoff Music Center · Noblesville, IN, USSet 2, song 17
- Oct 7, 2023Bridgestone Arena · Nashville, TN, USSet 2, song 15
- Jul 15, 2023Ameris Bank Amphitheatre · Alpharetta, GA, USSet 2, song 11
- Dec 30, 2022Madison Square Garden · New York, NY, USSet 2, song 13
- Apr 23, 2022Madison Square Garden · New York, NY, USSet 2, song 13
- Oct 29, 2021MGM Grand Garden Arena · Las Vegas, NV, USSet 1, song 7
- Aug 29, 2021The Gorge Amphitheatre · George, WA, USSet 2, song 18
- Feb 21, 2020Moon Palace The Grand · Cancún, ROO, MXSet 2, song 13
- Dec 8, 2019North Charleston Coliseum · North Charleston, SC, USSet 2, song 21
Think you can call the setlist?
Pick five songs before Phish takes the stage and score them live against everyone else in the room.
Play free